It ended up being AMAZING. I was very pleasantly surprised! Origionally we just boight this due to our household love of nightmare before christmas. But i opened it up and didnt close it til i finished it! It gave Sally an amazing story and due to watching nightmare before christmas oh I don't know 100x? It was very easy to visualize most of this book and follow it and I loved that! Sally is a personal favorite of mine and this book gave her an amazing ending or maybe beginning?